ZYGO Zygon® 0591-2385 1467-9744 10.1111/j.1467-9744.1993.tb01016.x EVOLUTION OF THE HUMAN CAPACITY FOR BELIEFS Goodenough Ward H. 02 03 1993 28 1 10.1111/zygo.1993.28.issue-1 5 27

Abstract. Evolution of the human capacity for beliefs is considered in relation to the emergence in human phylogeny of the ability to formulate propositions, evaluate their worth as bases for action, and make emotional attachments to them. Most of the relevant capabilities had appeared in primate evolution before the emergence of the Hominidae. The combination of capabilities peculiar to evolving hominines was that involved in the development of language, which ontogenetic evidence suggests began as a tool for implementing intentionality in social interaction and whose subsequent elaboration was associated with later reportorial and narrative uses.

 beliefs cognition human evolution language Bickerton, Derek.1981. Roots of Language. Ann Arbor : Karoma Publishers. Black, Mary.1973. “Belief Systems  .” In Handbook of Social and Cultural Anthropology, ed. JohnJ. Honigmann. Chicago : Rand McNally. Bower, T. R. G.1974. Development in Infancy. San Francisco : W. H. Freeman. Bower, T. R. G., J. M.Broughton, and M. K.Moore. 1970. “Demonstration of Intention in the Reaching Behaviour of Neonate Infants. Nature  228:679–80. Cann, Rebecca L., MarkStoneking, and Allan C.Wilson. 1987. “Mitochondrial DNA and Human Evolution. Nature  325:31–36. Chase, Philip G., and Harold L.Dibble. 1987. “Middle Paleolithic Symbolism: A Review of Current Evidence and Interpretations  . Journal of Anthropological Archaeology6: 263–96. Cheney, Dorothy, RobertSeyfarth, and BarbaraSmuts. 1986. “Social Relationships and Social Cognition in Nonhuman Primates. Science  234: 1361–66. Chiang, Kwang‐chih.1986. The Archaeology of Ancient China. 4th ed. New Haven : Yale Univ. Press. Crystal, David.1978. “The Analysis of Intonation in Young Children  .” In Communicative and Cognitive Abilities‐Early Behavioral Assessment, ed. FredD. Minifie and LyleL. Lloyd. Baltimore : University Park Press. Danziger, Eve.1988. “Language and the Brain: Questions of Interest to Anthropology  .” Unpublished manuscript in author's possession. Davidson, Iain, and WilliamNoble.1989. “The Archaeology of Perception: Traces of Depiction and Language. Current Anthropology  30: 125–55. deVillers, Jill G., and Peter A.deVillers. 1978. “Semantics and Syntax in the First Two Years: The Output of Form and the Form and Function of Input  .” In Communicative and Cognitive Abilities  See Crystal 1978. Diaz, Rafael M.1986. “The Union of Thought and Language in Childrens' Private Speech. The Quarterly Newsletter of the Laboratory of Human Cognition  8:90–97. Dibble, Harold L.1987. “The Interpretation of Middle Paleolithic Scraper Morphology. American Antiquity  52:109–17. Dibble, Harolla L.1988. “Typological Aspects of Reduction and Intensity of Utilization of Lithic Resources in the French Mousterian  .” In Upper Pleistocene Prehistory of Western Eurasia, ed. Harold L.Dibble and AntaMontet‐White. University Museum Symposium Seriess, vol. 1. Philadelphia : The University Museum, Univ. of Pennsylvania. Dibble, Harolla L.1989. “The Implications of Stone Tool Types for the Presence of Language during the Middle Pleistocene  .” In The Human Revolution, ed. PaulMellars and ChrisStringer. Princeton , N.J. : Princeton Univ. Press. Essock‐Vitale, Susan, and RobertM. Seyfarth.1986. “Intelligence and Social Cognition  .” In Primate Societies, ed. Barbara B.Smutset al. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press. Fantz, Robert L.1961. “The Origin of Form Perception. Scientific American  204(5): 66–72. Foley, Robert.1987. “Hominid Species and Stone‐tool Assemblages: How They Are Related. Antiquiy  61:380–92. Gelman, Rochel.1983. “Recent Trends in Cognitive Development  .” In The G. Stanley Hall Lecture Series Vol. 3, ed. C. J.Schierer and A. M.Rogers. Washington , D.C. : American Psychological Association. Girschner, Max.1912. “Die Karolineninsel Namoluk und ihre Bewohner. Baessler Archiv  2:123–215. Givón, T.1979. On Understanding Grammar. New York : Academic Press. Givón, T.1989. Mind, Code, and context. Hillsdale , N.J. : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Goodall, Jane.1986. The Chimpanzees Of Gombe. Cambridge , Mass. : Harvard Univ. Press, Belknap Press. Goodenough, Ward H.1963. Cooperation in Change. New York : Russell Sage Foundation. Goodglass, H., and E.Kaplan. 1983. The Assessment Of Aphasia and Related Disorders. Philadelphia : Lea and Febiger. Gruhn, Ruth.1988. “Linguistic Evidence in Support of the Coastal Route of Earliest Entry into the New World. Man  23:77–100. Harlow, H. F.1971. Learning to Love. New York : Ballantine Books. Harlow, H. F., and R. R.Zimmerman. 1959. “Affectional Responses in the Infant Monkey. Science  130:421–32. Hill, Jane H.1972. “On the Evolutionary Foundation of Language. American Anthropologist  74:308–17. Hockett, Charles F.1985. “Distinguished Lecture: F.American Anthropologist  87:263–81. Holloway, R. L.1983. “Human Paleontological Evidence Relevant to Language Behavior.;” Human Neurobiolou  2:105–14. Jardine, David W., and GriffithA.V.Morgan.1987. “Analogical Thinking in Young Children and the Use of Logico‐Mathematical Knowledge as a Paradigm in Jean Piaget's Genetic Epistemology. The Quarter& Newsletter of the Laboratory of Comparative Human Cognition  9:95–101. Kuhl, Patricia.1978. “Predispositions for the Perception of Speech–Sound Categories: A Species–Specific Phenomenon  ?” In Communicative and Cognitive Abilities  . See Crystal 1978. Laitman, Jeffrey T.1983. “The Evolution of the Hominid Upper Respiratory System and Implications for the Origins of Speech  .” In Glossogenetics: The Origin Evolution Of Language, ed. Eric deGrolier. Models of Scientific Thought, vol. 1. Paris : Harwood Academic Publishers. Lakoff, George.1987. Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things: What Categories Reveal about the Mind. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press. Lieberman, Philip, Edmund S.Crelin, and Dennis H.Klatt. 1972. “Phonetic Ability and Related Anatomy of the Newborn and Adult Human, Neanderthal Man, and the Chimpanzee.American Anthropologist  74:287–307. Luong, Hy Van.1986. “Language, Cognition, and Ontogenetic Development: A Reexamination of Piaget's Premises.Ethos  14:7–46. Mahler, Henry R.1973. Mitochondria: Molecular Biology, Genetics, and Development. Addison‐Wesley Module in Biology, no. 1. Reading, Mass.: Addison‐Wesley. Mellars, Paul.1989. “Major Issues in the Emergence of Modern Humans.Current Anthropology  30:349–85. Moore, M. Keith, and Andrew M.Meltzoff. 1978. “Object Permanence, Imitation, and Language Development in Infancy  .” In Communicative and Cognitive Abilities  . See Crystal 1978. Nelson, Katherine.1978. “Early Speech in Its Communicative Context  .” In Communicative and Cognitive Abilities  . See Crystal 1978. Nishida, Toshisada.1986. “Local Traditions and Cultural Transmission  .” In Primate Societies. See Essock–Vitale 1986. Oates, John F.1986. “Food Distribution and Foraging Behavior  .” In Primate Societies. See Essock‐Vitale 1986. Premack, Ann J.1976. Why Chimps Can Read. New York : Harper and Row. Sackett, James B.1988. “The Mousterian and its Aftermath: A View from the Upper Paleolithic  .” 1988. Schaerlaekens, A.M.1973. The Two‐Word Sentence in Child Language Development. The Hague: Mouton. Seyfarth, Robert M.1986. “Vocal Communication and Its Relation to Language  .” In Primate Societies. See Essock‐Vitale 1986. Slobin, Dan I.1985. “Introduction: Why Study Acquisition Crosslinguistically  ?” In The Crosslinguistic Study of Language Acquisition, vol. 1, ed. by Dan I.Slobin. Hillsdale , N.J. : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Spuhler, J.N.1988. “Evolution of Mitchondrial DNA in Monkeys, Apes, and Humans.Yearbook of Physical Anthropology  . Yearbook Series 31:15–48. Squire, Larry R.1986. “Mechanisms of Memory.Science  232:1612–19. Stebbins, W.C.1970. “Studies of Hearing and Hearing Loss in the Monkey  .” In Animal Psychophysics: The Design and Conduct of Sensory Experiments, ed. W.C.Stebbins. New York : Plenum Press. Sebbins, W.C.1973. “Hearing of Old World Monkeys. American Journal of Physical Anthropology  38:357–64. Stringer, Chris.1988. “The Dates of Eden.Nature  331:565–66. Stringer, C. B., and P.Andrews. 1988. “Genetic and Fossil Evidence for the Origin of Modern Humans.Science  239: 1263–68. Susman, Randall L.1988. “Hand of Paranthropus robustus from Member 1, Swartkrans: Fossil Evidence for Tool Behavior.Science  240:781–84. Valladas, H., et al.1988. “Thermoluminescence Dating of Mousterian ‘Proto‐Cro‐Magnon’ Remains from Israel and the Origin of Modern Man.Nature  331:614–16. Vygotsky, L. S.1962. Thought and Language. Boston : MIT Press. Wolpoff, Milford H.1989. “Multiregional Evolution: The Fossil Alternative to Eden  .” In The Human Reuolution. See Dibble 1989.