<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article
  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Publishing DTD v1.2 20120330//EN" "http://jats.nlm.nih.gov/publishing/1.2/JATS-journalpublishing1.dtd">
<article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"
         xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"
         article-type="research-article"
         dtd-version="1.2"
         xml:lang="en">
   <front>
      <journal-meta>
         <journal-id>ZYGO</journal-id>
         <journal-title-group>
            <journal-title>Zygon®</journal-title>
            <abbrev-journal-title/>
         </journal-title-group>
         <issn pub-type="print">0591-2385</issn>
         <issn pub-type="electronic">1467-9744</issn>
      </journal-meta>
      <article-meta>
         <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1111/j.1467-9744.2009.01033.x</article-id>
         <title-group>
            <article-title>ARGUMENTS FROM NOTHING: GOD AND QUANTUM COSMOLOGY</article-title>
         </title-group>
         <contrib-group>
            <contrib contrib-type="author">
               <name name-style="western">
                  <surname>Cahoone</surname>
                  <given-names>Lawrence</given-names>
               </name>
            </contrib>
         </contrib-group>
         <aff id="a1"/>
         <pub-date publication-format="electronic" iso-8601-date="2009-12-02">
            <day>02</day>
            <month>12</month>
            <year>2009</year>
         </pub-date>
         <volume>44</volume>
         <issue>4</issue>
         <issue-id pub-id-type="doi">10.1111/zygo.2009.44.issue-4</issue-id>
         <fpage>777</fpage>
         <lpage>796</lpage>
         <permissions>
            <copyright-statement>© 2009 by the Joint Publication Board of Zygon</copyright-statement>
         </permissions>
         <abstract>
            <p>This essay explores a simple argument for a Ground of Being, objections to it, and limitations on it. It is nonsensical to refer to Nothing in the sense of utter absence, hence nothing can be claimed to come from Nothing. If, as it seems, the universe, or any physical ensemble containing it, is past‐finite, it must be caused by an uncaused Ground. Speculative many‐worlds, pocket universes and multiverses do not affect this argument, but the quantum cosmologies of Alex Vilenkin, and J. B. Hartle and Stephen Hawking, which claim that the universe came from literally nothing, would. I argue that their novel project cannot work for reasons both physical (their “nothing” is actually a vacuum state governed by eternal physical laws) and methodological (physical theory cannot explain the emergence of the physical per se). Thus my argument stands. However, as David Hume showed, a posteriori arguments like mine infer a creation, and Creator, of a certain character, namely, a stochastic concept of creation and a panentheistic, partly physical Creator lacking omniscience and omnipotence. Rather than undermining the cosmological argument, as Hume intended, these limitations liberate the concept of the Ground from unnecessary problems, as Hartshorne suggested.</p>
         </abstract>
         <kwd-group>
            <kwd>Big Bang</kwd>
            <kwd>cosmological argument</kwd>
            <kwd>cosmology</kwd>
            <kwd>creation</kwd>
            <kwd>Creator</kwd>
            <kwd>God</kwd>
            <kwd>Hartle‐Hawking</kwd>
            <kwd>David Hume</kwd>
            <kwd>inflation</kwd>
            <kwd>no‐boundary proposal</kwd>
            <kwd>Nothing</kwd>
            <kwd>origin of universe</kwd>
            <kwd>past‐eternal</kwd>
            <kwd>past‐finite</kwd>
            <kwd>quantum cosmology</kwd>
            <kwd>quantum gravity</kwd>
            <kwd>teleological argument</kwd>
            <kwd>universe</kwd>
            <kwd>Alex Vilenkin</kwd>
         </kwd-group>
         <counts/>
      </article-meta>
   </front>
   <body/>
   <back>
      <ref-list>
         <ref id="b1">
            <mixed-citation id="cit1" publication-type="journal">Atkatz, David. 1994. “Quantum Cosmology for Pedestrians.<source>American Journal of Physics 
        </source>62:619–27.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b2">
            <mixed-citation id="cit2" publication-type="book">Anaximander of Miletus. 1988. <source>Chapter 3 of G. S. Kirk, J. E. Raven, and M. Schofield 
        </source>, The Presocratic Philosophers. 
            Cambridge
          : Cambridge Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b3">
            <mixed-citation id="cit3" publication-type="book">Barrow, John, and 
FrankTipler. 1986. The Anthropic Cosmological Principle. 
            Oxford
          : Oxford Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b4">
            <mixed-citation id="cit4" publication-type="book">
               <source>Bereshit Rabbah 
        </source>. 1985. The Judaic Commentary to the Book of Genesis: A New American Translation. Vol. I: Parashiyyot One through Thirty‐Three on Genesis 1:1 to 8:14. Trans. 
JacobNeusner. 
            Providence
            , 
            R.I.
          : Brown Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b5">
            <mixed-citation id="cit5" publication-type="journal">Borde, Arvind, 
Alan H.Guth, and 
AlexVilenkin. 2003. “Inflationary spacetimes are not past‐complete.<source>Physical Review Letters 
        </source>90 (15) (April 18):151301‐1
					to
					151301‐4.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b6">
            <mixed-citation id="cit6" publication-type="book">Cao, Tian‐yu. 2004. “<source>Ontology and Scientific Explanation. 
        </source>”
					In
					JohnCornwell, Explanations: Styles of Explanation in Science. 
            Oxford
          : Oxford Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b7">
            <mixed-citation id="cit7" publication-type="book">Clayton, Philip. 1997. God and Contemporary Science. 
            Grand Rapids
            , 
            Mich.
          : Eerdmans.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b8">
            <mixed-citation id="cit8" publication-type="book">Craig, William Lane, and 
QuentinSmith. 2003. Theism, Atheism, and Big Bang Cosmology. 
            New York
          : Oxford Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b9">
            <mixed-citation id="cit9" publication-type="journal">Curie, Pierre. 1894. “Sur la symétrie dans les phénomènes physiques. Symétrie d'un champ électrique et d'un champ magnétique.<source>Journal de Physique 
        </source>, 3d series, vol. 3:393–415.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b10">
            <mixed-citation id="cit10" publication-type="book">Davies, Paul. 1983. God and the New Physics. 
            New York
          : Simon and Schuster.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b11">
            <mixed-citation id="cit11" publication-type="book">Dombrowski, Daniel. 1996. Analytic Theism, Hartshorne, and the Concept of God. 
            Albany
          : State Univ. of New York Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b12">
            <mixed-citation id="cit12" publication-type="book">Eddington, Arthur S.1933. The Nature of the Physical World. 
            Cambridge
          : Cambridge Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b13">
            <mixed-citation id="cit13" publication-type="book">Guth, Alan. 1998. The Inflationary Universe: The Quest for a New Theory of Cosmic Origins. 
            New York
          : Perseus.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b14">
            <mixed-citation id="cit14" publication-type="journal">Hartle, J. B., and 
S. W.Hawking. 1983. “Wave Function of the Universe.<source>Physical Review D 
        </source>28:2960–75.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b15">
            <mixed-citation id="cit15" publication-type="book">Hartshorne, Charles. 1984. Omnipotence and Other Theological Mistakes. 
            Albany
          : State Univ. of New York Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b16">
            <mixed-citation id="cit16" publication-type="book">Hawking, Stephen. 1998. A Brief History of Time. 
            New York
          : Bantam.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b17">
            <mixed-citation id="cit17" publication-type="book">Hume, David. 1910. “<source>Of Providence and a Future State. 
        </source>”
					In
					An Enquiry into Human Understanding, Section XI. 
            New York
          : Collier.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b18">
            <mixed-citation id="cit18" publication-type="book">Hume, David. 1998. Dialogues concerning Natural Religion. 
            Indianapolis
          : Hackett.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b19">
            <mixed-citation id="cit19" publication-type="book">Isham, Christopher J.1993. “<source>Quantum Theories of the Creation of the Universe. 
        </source>”
					In
					Quantum Cosmology and the Laws of Nature: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action, Ed. 
RobertJohn Russell, 
NanceyMurphy, and 
Christopher J.Isham, 49–89. 
            Vatican City State
          : Vatican Observatory Publications.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b20">
            <mixed-citation id="cit20" publication-type="book">Kirschner, Robert P.2004. The Extravagant Universe: Exploding Stars, Dark Energy, and the Accelerating Cosmos. 
            Princeton
          : Princeton Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b21">
            <mixed-citation id="cit21" publication-type="other">Linde, Andre. 1994. “<source>The Self‐Reproducing Inflationary Universe. 
        </source>
               <source>Scientific American 
        </source> (November): 48–55.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b22">
            <mixed-citation id="cit22" publication-type="book">Lucretius. 1921. On the Nature of Things. Trans. 
WilliamEllery Leonard. 
            New York
          : E. P. Dutton.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b23">
            <mixed-citation id="cit23" publication-type="book">Neher, Andre. 1975. “<source>Visions du temps et l'histoire dans la culture juive. 
        </source>”
					In
					PaulRicoeur, Les cultures et le temps, 171–91. 
            Paris
          : Payot.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b24">
            <mixed-citation id="cit24" publication-type="book">Neville, Robert C.1968. God the Creator: On the Transcendence and Presence of God. 
            Chicago
          : Univ. of Chicago Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b25">
            <mixed-citation id="cit25" publication-type="book">Penrose, Roger. 2005. The Road to Reality: A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe. 
            New York
          : Knopf.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b26">
            <mixed-citation id="cit26" publication-type="book">Polkinghorne, John. 1989. Science and Creation. 
            Boston
          : Shambala.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b27">
            <mixed-citation id="cit27" publication-type="book">Prigogine, Ilya, and 
IsabelleStengers. 1984. Order out of Chaos: Man's New Dialogue with Nature. 
            New York
          : Bantam.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b28">
            <mixed-citation id="cit28" publication-type="book">Ramsey, Frank. 1990. “<source>Law and Causality B: General Propositions and Causality. 
        </source>Philosophical Papers, Ed. 
D. H.Mellor. 
            Cambridge
          : Cambridge Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b29">
            <mixed-citation id="cit29" publication-type="book">Rolston, HolmesIII. 1988. Environmental Ethics: Duties to and Values in the Natural World. 
            Philadelphia
          : Temple Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b30">
            <mixed-citation id="cit30" publication-type="book">Russell, Robert John. 1993. “<source>Finite Creation without a Beginning: The Doctrine of Creation in Relation to Big Bang and Quantum Cosmologies. 
        </source>”
					In
					Quantum Cosmology and the Laws of Nature: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action, Ed. 
RobertJohn Russell, 
NanceyMurphy, and 
Christopher J.Isham, 293–330. 
            Vatican City State
          : Vatican Observatory Publications.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b31">
            <mixed-citation id="cit31" publication-type="book">Russell, Robert John, 
NanceyMurphy, and 
Christopher J.Isham. 1993. Quantum Cosmology and the Laws of Nature: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action. 
            Vatican City State
          : Vatican Observatory Publications.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b32">
            <mixed-citation id="cit32" publication-type="book">Schelling, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Von. 1936. Philosophical Inquiries into the Nature of Human Freedom. Trans. 
J.Guttman. 
            New York
          : Open Court.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b33">
            <mixed-citation id="cit33" publication-type="journal">Smith, Quentin. 1998. “Why Stephen Hawking's Cosmology Precludes a Creator.<source>Philo: A Journal of Philosophy 
        </source>1 (1): 75–94.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b34">
            <mixed-citation id="cit34" publication-type="book">Smolin, Lee. 1997. The Life of the Cosmos. 
            Oxford
          : Oxford Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b35">
            <mixed-citation id="cit35" publication-type="book">Smolin, Lee. 2001. Three Roads to Quantum Gravity. 
            New York
          : Basic Books.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b36">
            <mixed-citation id="cit36" publication-type="book">Stenger, Victor. 2006. “<source>Why Is There Something Rather Than Nothing? 
        </source>Skeptical Briefs Newsletter, Vol. 16 (June). Committee for Skeptical Inquiry. <ext-link xlink:href="http://www.csicop.org/sb/show/why_is_there_something_rather_than_nothing">http://www.csicop.org/sb/show/why_is_there_something_rather_than_nothing</ext-link>.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b37">
            <mixed-citation id="cit37" publication-type="other">Tegmark, Max. 2003. “<source>Parallel Universes. 
        </source>
               <source>Scientific American 
        </source> (May): 41–51.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b38">
            <mixed-citation id="cit38" publication-type="journal">Tryon, Edward. 1973. “Is the Universe a Vacuum Fluctuation?<source>Nature 
        </source>246:396–97.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b39">
            <mixed-citation id="cit39" publication-type="book">Tillich, Paul. 1951. Systematic Theology. Vol. 1. 
            New York
          : Harper and Row.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b40">
            <mixed-citation id="cit40" publication-type="book">Tillich, Paul. 1952. The Courage to Be. 
            New Haven
          : Yale Univ. Press.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b41">
            <mixed-citation id="cit41" publication-type="journal">Vilenkin, Alex. 1982. “Creation of Universes from Nothing.<source>Physical Letters 
        </source>117B:25–28.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b42">
            <mixed-citation id="cit42" publication-type="journal">Vilenkin, Alex. 1984. “Quantum Creation of Universes.<source>Physical Review D 
        </source>30 (2) (July 15): 509–11.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b43">
            <mixed-citation id="cit43" publication-type="book">Vilenkin, Alex. 2006. Many Worlds in One: The Search for Other Universes. 
            New York
          : Hill and Wang.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
         <ref id="b44">
            <mixed-citation id="cit44" publication-type="book">Wilczek, Frank, and 
BetsyDevine. 1989. Longing for the Harmonies: Themes and Variations from Modern Physics. 
            New York
          : Norton.
</mixed-citation>
         </ref>
      </ref-list>
   </back>
</article>
