ZYGO Zygon® 0591-2385 1467-9744 10.1111/j.1467-9744.2010.01083.x THE IMPORTANCE OF MAGIC TO SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS Palmer Craig T. Steadman Lyle B. Cassidy Chris Coe Kathryn 02 06 2010 45 2 10.1111/zygo.2010.45.issue-2 317 337 © 2010 by the Joint Publication Board of Zygon

Many anthropological explanations of magical practices are based on the assumption that the immediate cause of performing an act of magic is the belief that the magic will work as claimed. Such explanations typically attempt to show why people come to believe that magical acts work as claimed when such acts do not identifiably have such effects. We suggest an alternative approach to the explanation of magic that views magic as a form of religious behavior, a form of communication that promotes or protects cooperative social relationships. We suggest that all forms of religious behavior involve persons communicating acceptance of a supernatural claim and that this act communicates a willingness to accept nonskeptically the influence of the person making such a claim. Thus, religious behavior communicates a willingness to cooperate with the claim maker and others who accept his or her influence. We suggest that magic, which can be distinguished by the communicated acceptance of the claim that certain techniques have supernatural effects, also promotes cooperation. Different types of magic, including sorcery, love magic, and curing magic, can be shown to communicate different types of messages, such as a threat to use violence to punish unsocial behavior, sexual desire, or concern for a person's well‐being. Ethnographic examples are used to support this hypothesis. This approach requires no assumptions about whether the practitioners of magic do or do not believe that the magical acts work as claimed. It attempts only to account for the identifiable talk and behavior that constitute magical acts by examining the identifiable, and often important, effects of these acts on the behavior of others.

 belief communication cooperation magic Andersen, Raoul. 1972. “Hunt and Deceive: Information Management in Newfoundland Deep‐Sea Trawler Fishing.”  In North Atlantic Fishermen, ed. RaoulAndersen and CatoWadel, 120–40. St. John's : Memorial Univ. of Newfoundland. Atran, Scott. 2002. In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion. New York : Oxford Univ. Press. Bell, Catherine M.2002. “‘The Chinese believe in spirits’: Belief and believing in the study of religion.”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 100–116. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Berryman, Edward. 2005. “Belief, apparitions, and rationality: The social scientific study of religion after Wittgenstein.”Human Studies  28:15–39. Bloch, Maurice. 1996. How We Think They Think: Anthropological Approaches to Cognition, Memory, and Literacy. Boulder , Colo. : Westview. Bloch, Maurice. 2002. “Are religious beliefs counter‐intuitive?”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 129–46. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Boyer, Pascal. 1994. The Naturalness of Religious Ideas. Berkeley : Univ. of California Press. Boyer, Pascal. 2001. Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought. New York : Basic Books. Braarvig, Jens. 1999. “Magic: Reconsidering the grand dichotomy.”  In The World of Ancient Magic: Papers from the First International Samson Eitern Seminar at the Norwegian Institute at Athens, 4–8 May 1997, ed. David R.Jordan, HugoMontgomery, and EinarThomassen, 21–54. Bergen , Norway : Norwegian Institute. Burkert, Walter. 1996. Creation of the Sacred: Tracks of Biology in Early Religions. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press. Cannon, Walter B.1942. “‘Voodoo’ death.”American Anthropologist  44:169–81. Cronk, Lee. 1994. “Evolutionary Theories of Morality and the Manipulative Use of Signals.”Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science  29:81–101. Davidson, Donald. 1999. “The myth of the subjective.”  In Language, Truth, and Religious Belief: Studies in Twentieth‐Century Theory and Method in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry and Hans H.Penner, 296–310. Atlanta , Ga. : Scholars. Elkin, Adolphus Peter. 1964. The Australian Aborigines. Garden City , N.Y. : Doubleday. Evans‐Pritchard, Edward Evan. 1937. Witchcraft, Oracles, and Magic among the Azande. Oxford : Clarendon. Evans‐Pritchard, Edward Evan. 1965. Theories of Primitive Religion. Oxford : Clarendon. Flood, Gavin. 1999. Beyond Phenomenology: Rethinking the Study of Religion. London : Cassell. Foster, Kevin R., and HannaKokko. 2009. “The evolution of superstitious and superstitionlike behaviour.”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B  276:31–37. Frank, Robert H.1988. Passions within Reason: The Strategic Role of Emotions. New York : W. W. Norton. Frankenberry, Nancy. 1987. Religion and Radical Empiricism. Albany : State Univ. of New York Press. Frankenberry, Nancy. 2002. “Religion as a ‘mobile army of metaphors.’”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 171–87. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Frazer, James. 1951. The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion. New York : Macmillan. Godlove, Terry F.Jr.2002. “Saving belief: On the new materialism in religious studies.”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 10–24. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Goffman, Erving. 1959. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Garden City , N.Y. : Doubleday. Habermas, Jürgen. 1979. Communication and the Evolution of Society. Trans. and intro. ThomasMcCarthy. Boston : Beacon. Hahn, Robert A.1973. “Understanding beliefs: An essay on the methodology of the statement and analysis of belief systems.”Current Anthropology  14:207–29. Haviland, William A.1983. Cultural Anthropology. New York : CBS College Publishing. Hilty, Donald M.1988. “Religious belief, participation and consequences: An exploratory and confirmatory analysis.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion  27:243–59. Hinde, Robert A.1999. Why Gods Persist: A Scientific Approach to Religion. London and New York : Routledge. Hogbin, Ian. 1964. Guadalcanal Society. New York : Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Hulkrantz, Ake. 1983. “The concept of the supernatural in primal religion.”History of Religions  22 (3): 231–53. Humphrey, Caroline, and JamesLaidlaw. 1994. The Archetypal Actions of Ritual: A Theory of Ritual Illustrated by the Jain Rite of Worship. New York : Oxford Univ. Press. Hunter, David E., and PhillipWhitten. 1976. Encyclopedia of Anthropology. New York : Harper and Row. Irons, William. 2001. “Religion as a hard‐to‐fake sign of commitment.”  In Evolution and the Capacity for Commitment, ed. R. M.Neese, 292–309. New York : Russell Sage Foundation. Jakobson, Roman. 1960. “Concluding Statement: Linguistics and Poetics.”  In Style in Language, ed. Thomas A.Sebeok, 350–77. Cambridge : MIT Press. James, William. 1979. The Will to Believe and Other Essays in Popular Philosophy. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press. Jensen, Jeppe Sinding. 2003. The Study of Religion in a New Key: Theoretical and Philosophical Groundings in the Comparative and General Study of Religion. Langelandsgade , Denmark : Aarhus Univ. Press. Kirsch, Thomas G.2004. “Restaging the will to believe: Religious pluralism, anti‐syncretism, and the problem of belief.”American Anthropologist  106:699–709. Klemke, E. D.1999. “Are religious statements meaningful?”  In Language, Truth, and Religious Belief: Studies in Twentieth‐Century Theory and Method in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry and Hans H.Penner, 57–75. Atlanta , Ga. : Scholars. Kluckhohn, Clyde. [1942] 1972. “Myths & rituals: A general theory.”  In Reader in Comparative Religion: An Anthropological Approach, 3d ed., ed. W.Lessa and E.Vogt, 66–77. New York : Harper and Row. Kluckhohn, Clyde, and DorotheaLeighton. 1962. The Navajo. Garden City , N.Y. : Anchor Books, Doubleday. Kottak, Conrad. 1974. Cultural Anthropology. New York : Random House. Laurier, Eric. 2004. “The spectacular showing: Houdini and the wonder of ethnomethodology.”Human Studies  27:377–99. Lavenda, Robert, and EmilySchultz. 2003. Core Concepts in Cultural Anthropology. Boston : McGraw‐Hill. Lawson, Thomas E., and Robert N.McCauley1984. “Functionalism Reconsidered.”History of Religions  23:372–81. Lawson, Thomas E.1990. Rethinking Religion: Connecting Cognition and Culture. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Malinowski, Bronislaw. 1931. “Culture.”  In Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, Vol. IV, ed. E.Seligman and A.Johnson, 634–42. New York : Macmillan. Malinowski, Bronislaw. 1979. “The role of magic and religion.”  In Reader in Comparative Religion: An anthropological Approach, 4th ed., ed. W.Lessa and E.Vogt, 37–46. New York : Harper and Row. Nadel, Siegfried. 1977. “Magic thinking.”Canberra Anthropology  1:1–14. Needham, Rodney. 1972. Belief, Language, and Experience. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press. Palmer, Craig T.1989. “The ritual taboos of fishermen: An alternative explanation.”Maritime Anthropological Studies  2:59–68. Palmer, Craig T.1990. “Telling the Truth (Up to a Point): Radio Communication among Maine Lobstermen.”Human Organization  49 (2): 157–63. Palmer, Craig T.1991. “Kin‐Selection, Reciprocal Altruism and Information Sharing among Maine Lobstermen.”Ethology and Sociobiology  12 (3): 221–36. Palmer, Craig T., and Lyle B.Steadman. 2004. “With or without belief: A new approach to the definition and explanation of religion.”Evolution and Cognition  10:138–47. Palmer, Craig T., Lyle B.Steadman, and ChrisCassidy2006. “Traditional religious ritual sacrifice: Cultural materialism, costly signaling, or descendant‐leaving strategy?”Journal of Ritual Studies  20:33–42. Penner, Hans H.1999. “What's wrong with functional explanations?”  In Language, Truth, and Religious Belief: Studies in Twentieth‐Century Theory and Method in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry and Hans H.Penner, 246–72. Atlanta, Ga.: Scholars. Penner, Hans H.2002. “You don't read a myth for information.”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 153–70. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Peoples, James, and GarrickBailey2000. Humanity, an Introduction to Cultural Anthropology. Belmont , Calif. : Wadsworth. Proudfoot, Wayne L.2002. “Religious belief and naturalism.”  In Radical Interpretation in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry, 78–92. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Rappaport, Roy. 1979. “Ritual, sanctity, and cybernetics.”  In Reader in Comparative Religion, 4th ed., ed. W. A.Lessa and E. Z.Vogt, 254–66. New York : HarperCollins. Romberg, Raquel. 2003. Witchcraft and Welfare: Spiritual Capital and the Business of Magic in Modern Puerto Rico. Austin : Univ. of Texas Press. Rozin, Paul, and CarolNemeroff1990. “The laws of sympathetic magic: A psychological analysis of similarity and contagion.”  In Cultural Psychology: Essays on Comparative Human Development, ed. James W.Stigler, Richard A.Shweder, and GilbertHerdt, 205–32. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Saler, Benson. 1974. “Review of Belief, Language, and Experience by R. Needham”American Anthropologist  76:861–66. Smith, Pierre. 1982. “Aspects of the Organisation of Rites.”  In Between Belief and Transgression: Structuralist Essays in Religion, History and Myth, ed. MichaelIzard and PierreSmith, trans. JohnLeavitt, 103–28. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press. Sosis, Richard. 2000. “Religion and intragroup cooperation: Preliminary results of a comparative analysis of utopian communities.”Cross-Cultural Research  34:71–88. Sosis, Richard. 2003a. “Cooperation and Commune Longevity: A Test of Costly Signaling Theory of Religion.”Cross Cultural Research  37:211–39. Sosis, Richard. 2003b. “Why Aren't We All Hutterites? Costly Signaling Theory and Religious Behavior.”Human Nature  14:91–127. Sosis, Richard. 2004. “The Adaptive Value of Religious Ritual.”American Scientist  92:166–72. Sosis, Richard, and CandaceAlcorta2003. “Signaling, solidarity, and the sacred: The evolution of religious behaviour.”Evolutionary Anthropology  12:264–70. Sosis, Richard, and Bradley J.Ruffle. 2004. “Reply.”Current Anthropology  45:530–31. Sperber, Dan. 1982. “Apparently Irrational Beliefs.”  In Rationality and Relativism, ed. MartinHollis and StevenLukes, 149–80. Oxford : Blackwell. Steadman, Lyle B.1975. “Cannibal witches among the Hewa.”Oceania  12:114–21. Steadman, Lyle B.1985. “The killing of witches.”Oceania  56:106–23. Steadman, Lyle B., and Craig T.Palmer. 1995. “Religion as an identifiable traditional behavior subject to natural selection.”Journal of Social and Evolutionary Systems  18 (2): 149–64. Steadman, Lyle B., and Craig T.Palmer. 2008. The Supernatural and Natural Selection: The Evolution of Religion. Boulder , Colo. : Paradigm. Styers, Randall. 2004. Making Magic: Religion, magic, and science in the modern world. New York : Oxford Univ. Press. Tambiah, Stanley Jeyaraja. 1985. Culture, Thought, and Social Action: An Anthropological Perspective. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press. Tambiah, Stanley Jeyaraja. 1990. Magic, Science, Religion, and the Scope of Rationality. Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press. Thomas, Keith. 1975. “An anthropology of religion and magic, II.”Journal of Interdisciplinary History  6:91–109. Thomassen, Einar. 1999. “Is magic a subclass of ritual?”  In The World of Ancient Magic: Papers from the First International Samson Eitern Seminar at the Norwegian Institute at Athens, 4–8 May 1997, ed. David R.Jordan, HugoMontgomery, and EinarThomassen, 55–66. Bergen , Norway : Norwegian Institute. Thornhill, Randy, and Craig T.Palmer. 2000. A Natural History of Rape: The Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion. Cambridge : MIT Press. Thourangeau, Roger, and RobertSternberg1981. “Aptness in metaphor.”Cognitive Psychology  13:27–55. WarnerW. Lloyd. [1937] 1964. Black Civilization: A Study of an Australian Tribe. New York : Harper and Row. Watanabe, John M., and Barbara B.Smuts. 1999. “Explaining Religion without Explaining It Away: Trust, Truth, and the Evolution of Cooperation.” in The Obvious Aspects of Ritual. Ecologies for Tomorrow: Reading Rappaport Today. Contemporary Issues Forum, ed. AlettaBiersackAmerican Anthropologist  101:98–112. Wells, Wesley R.1921. “Is supernatural belief essential in a definition of religion?”The Journal of Philosophy  18:269–74. Wilson, David Sloan. 2002. Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press. Winch, Peter. 1999. “Understanding a Primitive Society.”  In Language, Truth, and Religious Belief: Studies in Twentieth‐Century Theory and Method in Religion, ed. Nancy K.Frankenberry and Hans H.Penner, 342–77. Atlanta , Ga. : Scholars. Wittgenstein, Ludwig. 1966. Lectures and Conversation on Aesthetics, Psychology and Religious Belief. ed. C. K.Barrett. Berkeley : Univ. of California Press.