ZYGO Zygon® 0591-2385 1467-9744 10.1111/j.1467-9744.2010.01117.x AGNOSTIC MEDITATIONS ON BUDDHIST MEDITATION Deleanu Florin 02 09 2010 45 3 10.1111/zygo.2010.45.issue-3 605 626 © 2010 by the Joint Publication Board of Zygon

I first attempt a taxonomy of meditation in traditional Indian Buddhism. Based on the main psychological or somatic function at which the meditative effort is directed, the following classes can be distinguished: (1) emotion‐centered meditation (coinciding with the traditional samatha approach); (2) consciousness‐centered meditation (with two subclasses: consciousness reduction/elimination and ideation obliteration); (3) reflection‐centered meditation (with two subtypes: morality‐directed reflection and reality‐directed observation, the latter corresponding to the vipassanā method); (4) visualization‐centered meditation; and (5) physiology‐centered meditation. In the second part of the essay I tackle the problem of the epistemic validity and happiness‐engendering value of Buddhist meditation. In my highly conjectural view, the claim that meditation represents an infallible tool for realizing the (Supreme) Truth as well as a universally valid method for attaining the highest forms of happiness is largely based on the crēdō effect, that is, a placebolike process. I do not deny that meditation may have some positive effects on mental and physical health or that its practice may bring changes to the mind. Meditation may be a valuable alternative approach in life and clinical treatment, but it is far from being a must or a panacea.

 Buddhist meditation consciousness‐centered meditation crēdō effect Early Buddhism emotion‐centered meditation epistemology of meditation insight (vipassanā) Mahāyāna meditation and happiness physiology‐centered meditation placebo effect reflection‐centered meditation subject/object duality Tantric Buddhism Theravāda tranquility (samatha) visualization‐centered meditation Austin, James H.1998. Zen and the Brain: Toward an Understanding of Meditation and Consciousness. Cambridge : MIT Press. Benedetti, Fabrizio, AntonellaPollo, and LuanaColloca. 2007. “Opioid‐Mediated Placebo Responses Boost Pain Endurance and Physical Performance: Is It Doping in Sport Competitions?The Journal of Neuroscience  27(44): 11934–39. Carrington, Patricia. 1987. “Managing meditation in clinical practice  .” In The Psychology of Meditation, ed. Michael A.West, 150–72. Oxford : Clarendon. Chah, Achaan. [1985] 1997. “Observing Your Mind  .” In The Meditative Way: Readings in the Theory and Practice of Buddhist Meditation, ed. RodBucknell and ChrisKhan, 97–105. Richmond , Surrey : Curzon. Chalmers, Robert, ed. [1899] 1977. The Majjhima Nikāya. Vol. III. London : Pali Text Society. Coleman, James William. 2001. The New Buddhism: The Western Transformation of an Ancient Tradition. Oxford and New York : Oxford Univ. Press. Dasgupta, Shashi Bhushan. 1958. An Introduction to Tantric Buddhism. 2d ed. Calcutta , India : Univ. of Calcutta. Davids, T. W. Rhys, and J. EstlinCarpenter, eds. [1890] 1975. The Dīgha Nikāya. Vol. I. London : Pali Text Society. Davids, T. W. Rhys. [1903] 1966. The Dīgha Nikāya. Vol. II. London : Pali Text Society. Deleanu, Florin. [2000] 2005. “A Preliminary Study of Meditation and the Beginnings of Mahāyāna Buddhism  .” In Buddhism: Critical Concepts in Religious Studies, Vol. III, ed. PaulWilliams, 26–73. London and New York : Routledge. Dutt, Nalinaksha, ed. 1934. Pañcavi satisāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā. London : Luzac. Evans, Dylan. 2004. Placebo: Mind over Matter in Modern Medicine. New York : Oxford Univ. Press. Gazzaniga, Michael S., Richard B.Ivery, and George R.Mangun, with Megan S.Steven. 2009. Cognitive Neuroscience: The Biology of the Mind. 3d ed. New York and London : W. W. Norton. Gombrich, Richard, and GananathObeyesekere. 1988. Buddhism Transformed: Religious Change in Sri Lanka. Princeton : Princeton Univ. Press. Hardy, E., ed. [1899] 1958. The Anguttara Nikāya. Part IV. London : Pali Text Society. Harrington, Anne, ed. 1997. The Placebo Effect: An Interdisciplinary Exploration. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press. “Health Applications and Clinical Studies of Meditation  .” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_applications_and_clinical_studies_of_meditation. Kason, Yvonne. 2000. Farther Shores: Exploring How Near‐Death, Kundalini and Mystical Experiences Can Transform Ordinary Lives. Toronto : Harper Collins. “Kundalini Syndrome  .” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kundalini_syndrome. Lanotte, M., et al. 2005. “Expectation Enhances Autonomic Responses to Stimulation of the Human Subthalamic Limbic Region. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity  19:500–509. Lévi, Sylvain, ed. 1907. Asanga Mahāyāna‐Sūtrāla mkāra: Exposé de la doctrine du Grand Véhicule selon le système Yogacara. Vol. I. Paris : Libraire Honoré Champion. Lutz, Antoine, John D.Dunne, and Richard J.Davidson. 2007. “Meditation and the Neuroscience of Consciousness  .” In The Cambridge Handbook of Consciousness, ed. Philip DavidZelazo, MorrisMoscovitch, and EvanThompson, 499–551. Cambridge and New York : Cambridge Univ. Press. Lutz, Antoine, Heleen A.Slagter, John D.Dunne, and Richard J.Davidson. 2008. “Attention regulation and monitoring in meditation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences  12(4): 163–69. Matsunaga, Yukei, ed. 1978. The Guhyasamāja Tantra. Osaka : Toho shuppan. Mayberg, Helen S., et al.2002. “The Functional Neuroanatomy of the Placebo Effect. The American Journal of Psychiatry  159:728–37. Moerman, Daniel E., and Wayne B.Jonas. 2002. “Deconstructing the Placebo Effect and Finding the Meaning Response. Annals of Internal Medicine  136(6): 471–76. Morris, David B.1997. “Placebo, Pain, and Belief: A Biocultural Model  .” In The Placebo Effect: An Interdisciplinary Exploration, ed. AnneHarrington, 187–207. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press. National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2009 (updated). “Meditation: An Introduction  . http://nccam.nih.gov/. O'BoyleD. J., A. S.Binns, and J. J.Sumner. 1994. “On the Efficacy of Alcohol Placebos in Inducing Feelings of Intoxication. Psychopharmacology  115 (1–2): 229–36. Ospina, Maria B., et al.2007. “Meditation practices for health: State of the research  .” Evidence Report/Technology Assessment, Number 155. Agency for Healthcare and Research Publication, No 0–7‐E010 (June). “Placebo  .” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo. Pollo, Antonella, ElisaCarlino, and FabrizioBenedetti. 2008. “The Top‐down Influence of Ergogenic Placebos on Muscle Work and Fatigue. European Journal of Neuroscience  28(2): 379–88. Pradhan, P., ed. 1975. Abhidharmakosabhāsya of Vasubandhu. Patna : K. P. Jayaswal. Russell, Bertrand. [1946] 1987. A History of Western Philosophy. London : Unwin. Schmithausen, Lambert. 1981. “On Some Aspects of Descriptions or Theories of ‘Liberating Insight’ and ‘Enlightenment’ in Early Buddhism  .” In Studien zum Jainismus und Buddhismus. Gedenkschrift für Ludwig Alsdorf ed. KlausBruhn and AlbrechtWezler, 199–250. Wiesbaden : Alt‐ und Neu‐Indische Studien. Sferra, Francesco, and StefaniaMerzagora, eds. 2006. The Sekoddes tīkā by Nāropa (Paramārthasa graha). Roma : Istituto Italiano per l'Africa e L'Oriente. Slagter, Heleen A., AntoineLutz, Lawrence L.Greischar, Andrew D.Francis, SanderNieuwenhuis, James M.Davis, and Richard J.Davidson. 2007. “Mental Training Affects Limited Distribution of Limited Brain Resources. PLoS [Public Library of Science] Biology  5(6): e138 (www.plosbiology.org). Treckner, V., ed. [1988] 1979. The Majjhima Nikāya. Vol. I. London : Pali Text Society. Tucker, Jim B.2005. Life Before Life: Children's Memories of Previous Lives. New York : St. Martins Griffin. Vedantam, Shankar. 2002. “Against Depression a Sugar Pill Is Hard to Beat  .” The Washington Post, 7 May. Vetter, Tilmann. 1988. The Ideas and Meditative Practices of Early Buddhism. Leiden : E. J. Brill. Warren, Henry Clarke, ed. [1950] 1989. Visuddhimagga of Buddhaghosâcariya. Rev. Dharmananda Kosambi. Delhi : Motilal Banarsidass. West, Michael. A. ed. 1987. The Psychology of Meditation. Oxford : Clarendon.