JOHN POLKINGHORNE AND BERNARD LONERGAN ON THE SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF THEOLOGY

Edward M. Hogan; Edward M. Hogan

doi:10.1111/j.1467-9744.2009.01016.x

Research Articles
JOHN POLKINGHORNE AND BERNARD LONERGAN ON THE SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF THEOLOGY

Abstract

On the basis of his acquaintance with theoretical elementary particle physics, and following the lead of Thomas Torrance, John Polkinghorne maintains that the data upon which a science is based, and the method by which it treats those data, must respect the idiosyncratic nature of the object with which the science is concerned. Polkinghorne calls this the “accommodation” (or “conformity”) of a discipline to its object. The question then arises: What should we expect religious experience and theological method to be like if they are accommodated to the idiosyncratic nature of God? Polkinghorne's methodological program is typical of postcritical positions in the theology‐science dialogue in holding that the fiduciary element in theological method is simply a species of the fiduciary element that is a de facto part of all knowing—in other words, theological method does not differ in fundamental kind from the methods of the natural sciences. But this program may contain the seeds of an alienation of theological method from the transcendence of God similar to the double self‐alienation of theology described by Michael Buckley in At the Origins of Modern Atheism. I contend that something like Bernard Lonergan's position on how the method of faith seeking understanding is related to the methods of the natural sciences is exactly the sort of thing that one should expect on the supposition of Polkinghorne's principle of accommodation, at least if the God who is the object of theological science is transcendent. The way in which the divine differs from all other objects ought to be disclosed or reflected in religious experience and theological method. Polkinghorne charts the course for an accommodated theology, but it seems to be Lonergan who is more intent on following it.

Keywords

Bernard Lonergan, theological method, accommodation, At the Origins of Modern Atheism, John Polkinghorne, transcendence

How to Cite

Hogan, E., (2009) “JOHN POLKINGHORNE AND BERNARD LONERGAN ON THE SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF THEOLOGY”, Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 44(3), 558–582. doi: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9744.2009.01016.x

Rights

Download

Download XML
Download PDF

19

Views

27

Downloads

2

Citations

References

Buckley, Michael. 1987. At the Origins of Modern Atheism. New Haven : Yale Univ. Press.

Clayton, Philip. 1989. Explanation from Physics to Theology: An Essay in Rationality and Religion. New Haven : Yale Univ. Press.

Clayton, Philip. 1997. God and Contemporary Science. Grand Rapids , Mich. : Eerdmans.

Clayton, Philip. 1999. “Shaping the Field of Theology and Science: A Critique of Nancey Murphy. Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 34:609–18.

JohnPaulII. 1998. Fides et Ratio . Papal encyclical .

Lonergan, Bernard. 1967. “Cognitional Structure ”. In Collection: Papers by Bernard Lonergan, ed. F. E.Crowe, S.J., 221–39. New York : Herder and Herder.

Lonergan, Bernard. 1973. Philosophy of God and Theology. Philadelphia : Westminster Press.

Lonergan, Bernard. 1978. Insight. New York : Harper and Row.

Lonergan, Bernard. 1990. Method in Theology. Toronto : Univ. of Toronto Press.

Murphy, Nancey. 1990. Theology in the Age of Scientific Reasoning. Ithaca , N.Y. : Cornell Univ. Press.

Murphy, Nancey. 1999. “Theology and Science within a Lakatosian Program. Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 34:629–42.

Peacocke, Arthur. 2000. “Science and the Future of Theology: Critical Issues. Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 35:119–40.

Peterson, Gregory. 2000. “Going Public: Science‐and‐Religion at a Crossroads. Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 35:13–24.

Polkinghorne, John. 1986. One World. London : SPCK.

Polkinghorne, John. 1988. Science and Creation. Boston : New Science Library.

Polkinghorne, John. 1989. Rochester Roundabout. New York : W. H. Freeman.

Polkinghorne, John. 1991. Reason and Reality. Philadelphia : Trinity Press International.

Polkinghorne, John. 1994. The Faith of a Physicist: Reflections of a Bottom‐Up Thinker. Minneapolis : Fortress.

Polkinghorne, John. 1998. Belief in God in an Age of Science. New Haven : Yale Univ. Press.

Polkinghorne, John. 2000. Faith, Science and Understanding. New Haven : Yale Univ. Press.

Authors

Edward M. Hogan (Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science)

Download

Issue

Volume 44 • Issue 3 • September 2009

Publication details

Pages	558–582

Dates

Published	2009-09-02

Licence

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

Identifiers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9744.2009.01016.x

File Checksums (MD5)

XML: e0c8d7663961b0cab4e1b0d616cca88a
PDF: 8af57e4d0faf3ec052c24b267b1ae327

Abstract

Keywords

How to Cite

Rights

Download

19

27

2

References

Share

Authors

Download

Issue

Publication details

Dates

Licence

Identifiers

File Checksums (MD5)

Table of Contents

Abstract

Keywords

How to Cite

Rights

Download

19

27

2

References

Share

Authors

Download

Issue

Publication details

Dates

Licence

Identifiers

File Checksums (MD5)

Table of Contents

Non Specialist Summary